Tuesday, January 04, 2005

The prayer of the traveler

The distance that makes one a traveler

  • The travelling by which rules change (fasting Ramadan, prayer subset numbers, permissability of female travel, duty of Friday and Eid prayers, duty of slaughtering in Eid, the period for which one may wipe the khuff) is the one for which one intends (i.e. starts travelling wanting) to travel the distance of 3 complete days and nights at the average pace of a person on foot or riding a camel. Today this is estimated by about 98 kilometers.
  • Travel by sea is not estimated according to travel by land. Instead, one estimates according to normal conditions of travel by sea.
  • The sinful and the obedient (to Allah) in his traveling is the same with regards to its license.

The description of the travelers prayer

  • The obligatory prayers of the traveller with 4 subsets are reduced to 2 subsets ONLY (not optional).
  • If a traveller prayed 4 subsets and sat (the time it takes to say the tashahhud) after the first pair, then the first pair become the obligatory prayer and the second an optional prayer. However, he has done something bad by delaying the salaam of the obligatory prayer.
  • If a traveller prayed 4 subsets and did not sit (the time it takes to say the tashahhud) after the first pair, then his obligatory prayer is invalid. This is because he effectively entered an optional prayer before he completed the obligation.
  • The one who missed a prayer while traveling, and makes it up after settling, prays it by 2 subsets. The one who missed a prayer while settled, and makes it up while traveling, prays in 4 subsets.

Group prayer with travelers

  • If a traveller entered as a follower behind a settled person in a 4 subset prayer, in the time of that prayer, then he competes 4 subsets.
  • If a traveller entered (note that it is the time of entry that matters) behind a settled person in a 4 subset prayer, after the time of the prayer has expired, then his prayer is invalid. This is because it is now making up a prayer for him and he is supposed to make up 2 subsets, not 4.
  • If a traveller leads settlers, then he says the salaam after 2 subsets while the others complete 4. They complete the 3rd and 4th subsets without reciting, but must recite in any subsets that they did not catch.
  • It is a virtue for the leader who is a traveller to say "complete your prayers, because we are travellers!" after having said the salaam.

Start- and end-points of being a traveler

  • If the traveller went beyond the buildings of his place of settlement, then he starts praying 2 subsets.
  • After exiting the town, he remains a traveller until he intends to settle in a town or village for 15 days or more. If he intended less, he will remain a traveller.
  • Settlement in the middle of the desert is not valid for ending the state of being a traveller.
  • If the traveller entered a town with the firm intention of leaving "tomorrow or after tomorrow", and never intended to stay for 15 days, then he shortens his prayer, even if years pass by.
  • If the muslim troops entered the warzone (non-muslim land) and intended to settle, they still shorten their prayer, even if they besieged a town or a fortress. This is because they are in the state between victory thus settlement and defeat thus retreat, so their place is not a place for settlement yet. The same is the case if they besieged (muslim) rebels against the Khaliifah in muslim lands outside the cities or at sea.
  • The intention of settlment for herders living in tents is valid, and is not invalidated merely by moving from one pasture to another.
  • If the traveller enters his home town, then he must complete all 4 subsets, even if he did not intend to stay.
  • Whoever had a hometown but emigrated to another town, remains a traveller if he should travel through his original hometown. This is provided that it is not also his hometown. The basic rule is that one's original hometown is invalidated as a "hometown" by taking another place as ones home, but not by mere travelling or settling in another town.
  • The place of settling is invalidated by settling somewhere else (because the new place is its equal) or by travelling (because it is contradictory to settling) or by reaching one's hometown.
  • If the traveller intended to settle in "Makkah and Mina" for 15 days, then he keeps shortening his prayer. Exempted here is if he intended to stay all nights in one of them, because settlement has to do with were you stay at night, so in this case he becomes a settler by entering the place he intends to stay at night.

The Prostration of Recital

  • There are 14 places for the prostration of recital in the Quran. These were noted in the mushaf of Uthman.
  • Note: The second prostration in surat-ul-Hajj is for the prayer (not of recital - in disagreement with Shafi3iy), whereas there IS a prostration in suurah "Saad" (in disagreement with Shafi3iy).
  • Note: The place for prostrating in suurah "Ha-Mim" is after aaya number 38 (not 37 as some scolars say). This is the saying of Omar, and is precautionary since it is allowed to postpone the prostration, but not the other way around.
  • These prostrations are all a duty upon both the recitor and the listener, even if the latter did not intend to listen.
  • If the leader of the prayer recited an aayah of prostration, then he prostrates and so does the followers.
  • If the follower recites an aayah of prostration, then neither he nor the leader should prostrate during the prayer or after it. However, if someone outside the prayer heard it, then this outsider must prostrate.
  • If those in a group prayer heard someone outside their prayer recite an aayah of prostration, then they do not prostrate during the prayer. However, they do prostrate it after the prayer.
  • If they did prostrate in the prayer for the reciting done outside their prayer, then this is invalid and they must repeat it after the prayer, but not the prayer itself.
  • If the leader of a prayer recited an aayah of prostration and someone outside the prayer heard it, but entered into the prayer after the leader had prostrated for the recital, then this man does not have to prostrate for it. This is provided that he entered while the leader was still in the same subset (rak^ah). If he enters the prayer before the leader prostrates, then he must prostrate, because he must do so even if he did not hear the reciting. However, if he did not enter the prayer, or did not catch the subset, then he must prostrate it.
  • Any prostration of recital that became a duty during the reciting of a particular prayer and was not performed in it, cannot be caught up afterwards. This is because it was a part of the actions of prayer (imposed by the recital of the prayer), and therefore has extra virtues, so it cannot be performed by a prostration that is deficient of these virtues.
  • The prostration of the prayer itself does not stand for the prostration of recital, unless one prostrates within three aayahs after it became a duty (with the intention to fulfill this duty in addition to the obligation of the prayer itself).
  • If someone recited an aayah of prostration while outside prayer and before having prostrated entered a prayer (without interruption by engaging in something unrelated - like chatting, or going to another corner of the room) in which he recited the same aayah and prostrated, then this prostration fulfills the duty of both recitings. However, if he recited it and prostrated for it and then prayed and recited it again in the prayer, then he must prostrate for this second reciting.
  • If someone repeated the same Aayah of prostration several times in the same session, then one prostration is enough for all of them.
  • If someone recited an Aayah of prostration once, prostrated, left the place of sitting, and subsequently came back and recited it again, then he needs to prostrate again. If he didn't prostrate the first time, then he needs to prostrate twice.
  • If the sitting of the listener changed, but not that of the recitor, then the duty of prostrating for the same aayah is renewed for the listener only.
  • If the sitting of the recitor changed, but not that of the listener, then the duty is renewed for the reciter only.
  • The one who wants to perform the prostration of recital says "Allahu Akbar" without lifting the hands, then he prostrates, then he says "Allahu Akbar" again and raises his head from the ground. There is no tashahhud or salaam.
  • To read a suurah, in prayer or otherwise, and leave out the aayah of prostration in it is disliked. This is because it looks like one is avoiding it out of pride. To read an aayah of prostration, and leave the rest of the suurah is acceptable.

Praying While Sick

  • If someone was too weak to be able to stand, then he performs bowings and prostrations while sitting. This is because obedience to Allah is according to ability.
  • If he is unable to sit, then he lies on his back, supported by a pillow to incline his upper body, and stretches his legs in the direction of the prayer, hinting at bows and prostrations.
  • If someone that is unable to sit lied down on his side facing his chest in the direction of the prayer while hinting, then his prayer is valid also. However, sitting with ones legs stretched is better, because the hints point in the prayer direction.
  • If someone was not able to hint by his head, then he delays the prayer and does not hint by his eyes, heart or eyebrows.
  • If someone is able to stand, but not to perform bowing and prostration, then he does not have to stand, but sits and hints at the movements. He may stand, but the best is to sit, because hinting while seated is closer to real prostration
  • If a healthy person performed some of his prayer standing but suddenly fell ill, then he completes while seated (prostrating or hinting as able), or lying on his back if necessary.
  • If someone praying seated, while performing complete bowings and prostrations due to illness, became well during the prayer, then he builds upon what has been done and performs the rest standing (i.e. he stands where it is required.)
  • If someone praying by hinting at bows and prostrations due to illness became well during it, then he must pray all over again.
  • If someone started praying optionally while standing but became weak, then it is acceptable for him to lean on a stick or wall, or to sit down. This is because this is an excuse.
  • If he started leaning during optional prayer without an excuse then this is disliked, because it is improper behavior.
  • If he sat (during an optional prayer - after having stood in the beginning) without an excuse, then it is disliked but valid.
  • If someone prays seated in a boat (while sailing) without being sick, then it is valid, but standing is better.
  • If the boat is tied to the shore, then one must pray on land if the boat is unstable; praying on the boat would be invalid.
  • The boat tied to an anchor in the middle of the sea takes the judgment of the boat sailing if there is a lot of movement. If it is stable, then one must stand.
  • The one who loses consciousness or sanity for 5 consecutive prayer times or less must make them up. If it was more, then he does not have to pray them.
  • The one who sleeps through prayers must make them up, no matter how many.

The Prostration of Inattentiveness (sujuud as-sahw)

These two extra prostrations at the end of prayer are a duty, because their role is to repair a defect that happened to the prayer during its performance, just like slaughtering during the pilgrimage if one has committed something prohibited.

Performing the prostration of inattentiveness

  1. Say the tashahhud
  2. Say the salam to both sides
  3. Prostrate twice for the inattentiveness that occurred
  4. Say the tashahhud
  5. The Salaat alaa-an-nabiyy
  6. Supplication (if you wish)
  7. Say the salam to both sides to end the prayer
These two prostrations are not repeatable, therefore they should be made after the first salam. However, it is valid to perform them before the salam and then end the prayer.

The basic causes for this duty

1. Postponing an obligation or a duty inattentively: The prostrations of inattentiveness are a duty if someone added an action in a prayer that does not belong to the prayer he is in, but it is of the kind of actions that are done in prayer. (E.g. prostrating 3 times in a subset or saying the salaatul-Ibrahmimiah after the first tashahhud)

2. Neglecting a duty, such as:
  • Reciting the FaatiHah (if one is the prayer leader or praying single)
  • Supplicating the qunuut of Witr prayer
  • Saying the tashahhud (both of them)
  • Sitting for the first tashahhud
  • The takbiiras of Eid prayer
  • Reciting more than 3 aayas of the Quran loudly when it should be silent
  • Reciting more than 3 aayas of the Quran silently when it should be loud

Prostrating for inattentiveness in a group prayer

  • If the leader prostrates for inattentiveness, then the follower must prostrate with him, but not if the leader did not prostrate.
  • If the follower made a mistake out of inattentiveness, then nobody prostrates for this.
  • It is valid to enter the prayer of a leader before he has said the salam after prostrating for inattentiveness.

Negligence in the first sitting for the tashahhud

  • The one who forgot the first sitting, but remembered while he was still closer to sitting (than standing), sits down and performs the tashahhud. The prostration of inattentiveness is not required in this case.
  • If he was closer to standing than sitting, then he does not return to sit, but must prostrate for this inattentiveness.

Negligence in the last sitting for the tashahhud

If someone omitted the last sitting and stood for a fifth subset, then:
  • He must return to sit unless he has prostrated once for this subset. He must perform the prostration of inattentiveness since he delayed an obligation.
  • If he prostrated once in this fifth subset, then his (and any follower’s) prayer is invalid as an obligation and has become an optional prayer.
If someone sat after the 4th subset and then stood for a fifth without saying the salaam first, then he returns to sit and say it as long as he has not prostrated in the fifth. His obligation is complete in either case. If he prostrated in the fifth, then a sixth subset is added so that the 2 extra subsets become an optional prayer. He must perform the prostration of inattentiveness at the end for leaving out the salaam.

3 special cases

  1. The person who prayed 2 optional subsets and was inattentive and prostrated for that in them, cannot build upon these 2 subsets if he wanted to add more subsets.
  2. The traveler who finished 2 subsets (while shortening) and prostrated for inattentiveness, but then intended to settle (to stay more than 15 days) before saying the salam: he must complete 4 subsets so as not to invalidate his entire prayer.
  3. The one who said the salaam intending to exit from the prayer, and still has prostrations of inattentiveness due, must still prostrate them.

Doubting the number of subsets prayed

If someone doubted whether he had prayed 3 or 4 subsets during prayer, then:
  • If this is the first time this happens, he must pray over again. One should exit from the prayer one is in by saying the salaam.
  • If this happens often, he goes by what he thinks is the most likely number of subsets prayed. If a more likely number of subsets does not occur to him, then he goes by the number he is sure of (i.e. the least number.) In the case of building upon the least number, the person should sit and perform the tashahhud at the end of every subset that he imagines might be the last. This is to avoid leaving out the obligation of the last sitting.

Catching up missed prayers or parts of group prayer

Catching part of the group prayer

  • The one who reached the group prayer while the leader was in the bowing position, then proscribed and remained standing until the leader stood up, has not caught this subset. He stands up and prays this subset and all others missed after the leader has completed his prayer.
  • If a follower bowed before the leader, then his bow was valid if the leader caught the follower in it, not otherwise. However, it is better to repeat the bow.

Catching Up Missed Obligatory Prayers

  • The correct sequence of missed prayers and the obligation of the current time is required, and leaving it invalidates the prayer, unless:
  • One fears that the time to pray the current obligation is running out
  • The missed prayers are more than 5
  • One forgot about the missed prayers until after the current time’s obligation

Making Up Missed Optional Prayers

  • The 2 optional subsets before Fajr are prayed after the group prayer has started, if one can catch the second subset with the leader, but outside the masjid. This is not for the optional subsets before other obligatory prayers.
  • If someone misses the Ascertained Merit (sunnah) before Fajr, then he does not pray it after Fajr unless he missed Fajr itself so he can pray it in combination with the missed Fajr.
  • Other ascertained sunnah prayers are caught up within their associated obligatory prayer's time, but not after.

Interrupting the prayer to join a group prayer

  • If someone completed his obligatory prayer alone, then he may join the group prayer afterwards as an optional prayer, but not after Fajr, Asr or Maghrib.
  • If he has not made the first prostration of the second subset of Fajr; he interrupts Fajr and joins the group.
  • If he had prostrated once in the 3rd subset of Thuhr, 2nd subset of Maghrib or Fajr then he completes the prayer.
  • If he was praying the sunnah mu'akkadah (ascertained merit) before Thuhr or the Friday Group Prayer, and then the group prayer or the speech started, then he interrupts after competing the first pair of subsets.

Witr Prayer

  • Witr's is a duty, has three consequtive subsets (no tasliim after the first sitting for tashahhud) with FatiHah and a suurah, and with a supplication (qunuut) before bowing in the 3rd subset.
  • When one wants to make the Witr Supplication, one raises the hands like in the proscription while saying "Allahu Akbar," then starts to supplicate silently.
  • There is no regularly prescribed qunut supplication (like the supplication of Witr) other than in Witr.
  • If there are calamities, such as war, one may make qunut supplication in other than Witr in the standing after the bow (rukuu^) in the last subset.
  • Followers remain silent if the leader of the prayer makes the qunuut supplication in Fajr.
  • Witr is prayed in group in Ramadan only, by the consensus of the muslims, and with loud reciting.

Optional Prayers

The optional prayers and their description

  • All subsets in optional prayer must have the FatiHah and a suurah recited in them because every pair of subset is like a separate prayer.
  • The number of subsets of optional prayers of the daytime are 2 or 4
  • During the night one may pray 2, 4, 6 or 8 subsets in one prayer.
  • The best number of subsets for optional prayers is 4.
  • The Merit (sunnah) prayers are: 2 subsets before Fajr, 4 in one prayer before Thuhr, 2 (or 4) after Thuhr, (2 or 4 before Asr), 2 after Maghrib, (2 or 4 before Eisha) and 2 (or 4) after Eisha. Those in brackets are not ascertained.
  • One does not leave the Merit prayers, unless time is running out for the obligatory prayer.
  • Duha is prayed by 4 subsets after the sun rises high, but before its zenith
  • The best place to pray optional prayers is in the house (except taraawiiH).
  • Ramadan’s TaraawiiH: 10 prayers of 2 subsets behind a leader, or alone at home, after the obligatory night prayer, with a resting period every 4 subsets.
  • A traveler outside the city prays optional prayers on the back of his animal in the direction it is facing, hinting at the prayer movements.
  • If someone started praying on the back of an animal, then descended and finished on the ground, then his prayer is correct, but not the other way around.
  • Optional prayers seated while able to stand are permitted. It is best to sit as in the tashahhud.
  • If someone started to pray an optional prayer standing, but later sat without an excuse, then this is valid.

The one who starts an optional prayer and then invalidates it must pray it later.

Since every pair of subset is like a separate prayer:

  • If someone was praying 4 subsets optionally, and invalidated the prayer after standing up for the 3rd subset, then he must pray 2 subsets later.
  • If one does not recite in a subset pair, then the proscription has been invalidated.
  • Reciting in only one subset of a pair of subsets invalidates that pair only.

Invalidators of Prayer

In prayer, the underlying cause of invalidation is a lot of activity that does not belong to the prayer:
  • Speaking in prayer, whether purposefully or forgetfully, invalidates it. An exception here is forgetfully saying the "assalam" saying during prayer.
  • If the leader of the prayer recited Qur'aan by reading from a book (not merely reading)
  • Entering another prayer by proscription (one has entered the other prayer)
  • If someone said "there is no god but God" intending it as an answer to someone else, but not if he intended by it to make someone aware that he was praying.
  • If someone helps in the reciting of someone other than the leader of the prayer he is in, then his prayer becomes invalid.
  • If someone helps his own leader remember in his reciting, it does not invalidate his prayer, unless the leader has already gone to another aayah. He should not hurry in this.
  • If someone sneezed, and someone who was praying said "raHimaka Allah" (bless you), then the latter's prayer is invalidated.
  • The one who clears his throat, and pronounces letters in doing so, invalidates his prayer unless he is excused by being unable to prevent it (i.e. naturally or to be able to recite), just like sneezing or belching.
  • If a person sighed, moaned or cried with letter-sounds in prayer, then it invalidates it unless it is because of remembering Paradise or Hell (not pain or adversity)
  • More than two consecutive movements
  • Killing scorpions or any type of snake during prayer is not harmful
  • The one who eats or drinks in prayer invalidates it, whether it was intentionally or not.
    • Exempted here is if you swallowed something that was already in your mouth before the prayer started and it was less that a chick-pea in size.
  • To answer a greeting during prayer invalidates it, if it is by the tongue or by shaking hands. It is disliked if it is done by giving a sign (such as a nod.)

Disliked acts related to prayer and the masjid

Disliked acts in the prayer

  • To count suuras or aayas of the Quran during prayer by the hand (not merely pressing the fingers into the body)For the leader of the prayer to stand (not just prostrate) in the arcade, or on a separate platform (or the followers being on a platform and the leader not).
  • To pray with a forbidden picture in front, over the head, to the side, behind, on the clothes or on the prayer rug.
    • To pray towards the back of a man sitting and having a conversation has no harm in it.
    • To pray with a copy of the Qur'aan or a sword hung up directly in front is not disliked.
    • If the head of a statue has been removed, then it is not considered a forbidden image.
    • It is not disliked to have a picture in the house on a pillow or a carpet on the floor, because it is stepped on.
    • The image of something that does not have a soul is not disliked (such as plants and trees).
  • It is disliked for the one in prayer to toy with his clothing, fingers, body or pebbles.
  • One may remove pebbles from the place of prostration by a single movement if it affects one's ability to perform it properly.
  • To place one's hands on the hips during prayer is disliked
  • Turning one's head in prayer is also disliked but turning one's eyes alone left and right during prayer is not
  • To sit on one's buttocks with the knees up in front during prayer is disliked
  • To put ones forearms on the ground in prostration is disliked
  • To sit cross-legged in prayer is disliked without an excuse
  • To lift and hold one's clothing while descending into prostration
  • For the man to have his hair collected in a ponytail or by pigment at the back.
  • To let one's clothes hang loosely from ones head and shoulders during prayer

Dislikes related to the masjid

  • Locking up the masjid is disliked, because it resembles prevention of prayer, unless one fears for the property in it outside the prayer times.
  • Ornamenting a masjid with gypsum, wood or gold paint has no sin in it, but it is not rewardable to do so. Some said it is if someone did it using his own money.
  • Intercourse, defecation, urination or having Greater Ritual Impurity above a public masjid is disliked, because its roof is like being inside it.

Passing in front of someone praying and using a sutrah

  • The one who passes between the praying person and the place he makes prostration has committed a sin -- unless there is a barrier between, such as a wall. It does not invalidate the prayer.
  • When praying in an open area, one should put a divider in front, about 70 cm high and wider than a finger.) One should stand close to the divider, and keep it a little to the left or right from the middle, so as not to pray directly towards it.
  • One may pray without the divider if one feels safe from anyone passing in front and one is not facing a road.
  • The divider in front of the leader works as a divider for all his followers.
  • The person praying prevents people from passing in front of him by either using the hand to stop them or by saying "subhaanallaah".

Entering a masjid in which the call for prayer had already been made

  • If the call has been made, then it is disliked to exit from the masjid until one has prayed. Exempted is the one who is part arranging the group prayer in another place.
  • If he had already prayed and it was the time of Eisha or Thuhr, then he may exit before the call to stand to pray starts, not after. For Fajr, Asr and Maghrib he exits regardless.